• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Fross Zelnick

  • People
  • Focus
  • Services

    Find Your Lawyer

    Shelby P. RokitoCharles T.J. Weigell, IIIKatherine Lyon DaytonMary StotteleJames D. WeinbergerCara A. BoyleCraig S. MendeChristina SauerbornJoyce M. FerraroNadine H. JacobsonLawrence Eli ApolzonDavid A. DonahueTodd MartinKimberly B. FrumkinDaniel M. NuzzaciRobin N. BaydurcanCarlos CucurellaAlexandra E. KochianAdrian E. Harrison Jr.Allison Strickland RickettsAlejandra Camacho LunaAndrew N. FredbeckNancy E. SabarraBrian LearyAngela García MedinaSara GoldmanMaritza C. SchaefferAlexandra LenczewskiAshford TuckerRichard Z. LehvRobin L. WarrenJames D. SilbersteinJohn P. MargiottaLeo KittayAmanda B. AgatiJason D. JonesLydia T. GobenaTamar Niv BessingerNicole LiebermanRobert A. BeckerJanet L. HoffmanLaura Popp-RosenbergJennifer GibbinsSherri N. DuitzNancy DiConzaSahil YadavCole S. MathewsKaren LimBarbara A. Solomon
    • A
    • B
    • C
    • D
    • E
    • F
    • G
    • H
    • I
    • J
    • K
    • L
    • M
    • N
    • O
    • P
    • Q
    • R
    • S
    • T
    • u
    • v
    • w
    • x
    • y
    • z
    • View All
ShareBookmarkPrintPDF

Search Again

Alerts September 16, 2017

Russian Federation: The Trisolen Case – A Lesson In Enforcement Against Trademark Infringement

No. 301-Aд17-4305

On May 15, 2017, the Supreme Court (highest court) of the Russian Federation upheld a decision of the Russian IP court (No. A43-10065/2016) which, at first glance, appears to undermine a trademark owner’s ability to enforce its marks against unauthorized third-party uses. 

The case concerns a Customs seizure of goods imported into the Russian Federation bearing the TRISOLEN mark.  The goods were manufactured and sold by Leuna Eurokkomerz GmbH, a German company that owned the mark in Germany.  A Russian company, MVT Trade LLC (“MVT”), that owns a Russian Federation registration for ТРИЗОЛЕН (TRIZOLEN in Cyrillic), objected to such import on the ground that TRISOLEN was confusingly similar to its ТРИЗОЛЕН mark.  MVT succeeded in the first instance and appellate courts. 

In a decision issued on February 9, 2017, however, the IP Court reversed, holding that the importation of goods into Russia bearing a trademark duly registered in the manufacturer’s country of origin could not constitute trademark infringement in Russia.  While this decision, on its face, seems to immunize such importation against infringement of a prior trademark registered in the Russian Federation, it must be noted that the case involved a customs seizure and was brought under the Code of Administrative Offenses (“COAO”),   The IP Court, based on a 2009 ruling of the Supreme Arbitrazh Court, found that the relevant Art. 14.10 of the COAO (governing trademark offenses) was not applicable to cases where imported goods bear a trademark duly registered by the manufacturer in the country of origin.  While one could question the reasoning of this case, it has so far been upheld by the higher courts. 

In a different parallel civil trademark infringement case, MVT prevailed before the IP Court (No. A43-26595-2015), a case that the Supreme Court refused to hear, making the IP Court decision final.  The lesson to be learned, at least for now, is that in similar cases, trademark owners appear better off enforcing their marks through civil lawsuits rather than Customs/COAO procedures.  

Primary Sidebar

Search Again

Related

People

  • Janet L. Hoffman

    Senior Counsel

Focus

  • Entertainment Properties

Services

  • International
  • Trademark
  • Sitemap
© 2023 Fross Zelnick
  • Fross Zelnick and FZ are registered trademarks of Fross Zelnick Lehrman & Zissu, P.C.
  • Attorney Advertising
  • Legal & Privacy
  • Connect with us on LinkedIn
  • Contact

Stay Connected

  • People
  • Focus
    • Celebrities, Bands & Athletes
    • Consumer Products
    • Entertainment Properties
    • Fashion
    • Startup & Emerging Growth
    • Food & Beverage
    • Hospitality & Hotels
    • Jewelry & Watches
    • Personal Care & Cosmetics
    • Pharmaceuticals
    • Professional Services
    • Publishing
    • Sports
    • Toys
  • Services
    • Trademark
    • Copyright
    • Design
    • Litigation
    • Transactions
    • Publicity & Privacy
    • Social Media & Domain Names
  • Decisions
  • Newsroom
  • Our Firm
    • About Our Firm
    • Contact
    • Recognition
    • Diversity & Inclusion
    • Pro Bono
    • Web TMS