• Skip to content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Fross Zelnick Lehrman & Zissu, P.C.®

  • People
  • Focus
  • Services

    Find Your Lawyer

    Joyce M. FerraroNicole TenoreDavid A. DonahueMaritza C. SchaefferCarlos CucurellaAndrew N. FredbeckAlexandra E. KochianCourtney B. ShierRobert A. HavasAdrian E. Harrison Jr.Amanda B. AgatiTamar Niv BessingerKatherine Lyon DaytonJohn P. MargiottaSherri N. DuitzAngela RamanauskasRoger L. ZissuEric T. GordonNancy DiConzaLaura Popp-RosenbergCole S. MathewsDarra FrinoBrian LearyRobin N. BaydurcanHalle MarkusLeo KittayMassimo B. CapizziJames D. SilbersteinRichard Z. LehvParker C. EudyAllison Strickland RickettsJason D. JonesMary StotteleTodd MartinEsteban Monge-MoreraAlejandra Camacho LunaShelby P. RokitoNadine H. JacobsonLydia T. GobenaChristina SauerbornNancy E. SabarraJames D. WeinbergerCraig S. MendeCarole E. KlingerAshford TuckerBarbara A. SolomonCharles T.J. Weigell, III
    • A
    • B
    • C
    • D
    • E
    • F
    • G
    • H
    • I
    • J
    • K
    • L
    • M
    • N
    • O
    • P
    • Q
    • R
    • S
    • T
    • u
    • v
    • w
    • x
    • y
    • z
    • View All
ShareBookmarkPrint

Search Again

Alerts November 18, 2026

November 2026 FZLZ Minute

USA 

Seventh Circuit says owner of copyright in a collection of articles has no automatic right to publish each individual article in the collection

Dr. Frederick Perls pioneered a form of psychotherapy called gestalt therapy. He wrote an article entitled “Psychopathology of Awareness” (the “Article”), but never published it before his death in 1970. The copyright passed to his wife and, after her death in 1991, “her estate entered into an agreement with The Center for Gestalt Development [the “Center”] that conveyed exclusive rights to publish a collection of Dr. Perls’ un-published manuscripts, a collection that included the [Article].”

In 2020, after gaining permission from Dr. Perls’ grandchildren to publish the Article in their book, Charles Bowman and Jean-Marie Robine published “Psycho-pathology of Awareness: An unfinished and unpublished manuscript with commentaries by contemporary gestalt-therapists.”

The Center sued Bowman and Robine for copyright infringement. The District Court granted summary judgment to the defendants. On appeal, the Seventh Circuit held that the Center’s right to publish Dr. Perls’ unpublished manuscripts did not give the Center ownership of the copyright in the individual articles.

The Seventh Circuit noted that “…the owner of a so-called compilation copyright does not necessarily own any rights to the underlying writings within the compilation.” The Court relied in part on Section 201(c) of the Copyright Act, which says, “In the absence of an express transfer of the copyright or of any rights under it, the owner of copyright in the collective work is presumed to have acquired only the privilege of reproducing and distributing the contribution as part of that particular collective work . . .”

The Center argued that Dr. Perls’ heirs had separately assigned the copyright in the Article to the Center. The Seventh Circuit held that the assignment occurred after the heirs had granted the defendants permission to reprint the Article in their book. The Court said, “So when the Center acquired the article’s copyright in 2021, it did so subject to a limitation on its otherwise-exclusive right to publish the article.” Accordingly, the Court affirmed the grant of summary judgment.

Richard Lehv

California Court allows public radio host to proceed with suit for AI copying of his voice

Greene was the host of National Public Radio’s “Morning Edition” from 2012 to 2020. He now hosts several podcasts and says that his programs “reach millions of listeners and have made [him] one of the most well-known and respected radio and podcasting voices of his time.”

In 2024, Google launched the Audio Overview feature of its AI product, NotebookLM. It transforms documents uploaded by the user “into a podcast-like conversation between two AI ‘hosts,’ one male and one female.” Greene alleged that Google “downloaded, trained on, and thereby misappropriated [his] voice and/or recordings featuring his voice.” Once trained, he claimed, the Google product converts text to speech and “replicates [his] unique vocal qualities, cadence, tone, pitch, and expressive style.”

Greene sued under a California right of publicity statute that prohibits the use of a person’s “name, voice, signature, photograph, or likeness” for commercial purpose. Google argued that the statute did not apply because Greene alleged only an imitation of his voice, “not a use of his ‘voice.’” The Court rejected this argument. It said, “As pleaded, Greene is the only human voice from which the male host’s voice derives.”

Greene also alleged common law misappropriation, which prohibits use of an imitation of a celebrity’s “distinctive voice” where the voice “is widely known and is deliberately imitated in order to sell a product.” The Court held that Greene had adequately pleaded all the elements of a misappropriation claim. It also held that Greene had adequately pleaded two other common law claims, for unfair competition and unjust enrichment. Finally, it held that Greene’s claims were not pre-empted by the Copyright Act, because his claims did not fall within copyright’s subject matter, and he did not assert rights equivalent to the rights of a copyright holder.

Richard Lehv

ADVERTISING

Key disclosure in the Keystone State: Pennsylvania will require labels on certain uses of AI content in ads

On October 22, 2026, Pennsylvania Governor Shapiro signed the Artificial Intelligence Deceptive Advertising Act (SB 806), effective December 21, 2026. The law covers advertisements containing AI-generated or significantly AI-modified images, video or audio, but only when such content is used “in a manner that creates a false consumer perception about the nature, origin, or authenticity of the goods or services being advertised.”

What “false consumer perception” means under the statute is open to interpretation. One reading suggests disclosure is required by the mere presence of AI-created content in an ad, but another suggests that disclosure is required only when such content is misleading. Pennsylvania’s consumer protection laws and the FTC Act establishing liability for deceptive advertising appear to overlap somewhat with this statute. Consequently, disclosing AI-generated content in an ad may not necessarily shield the advertiser from liability if such content nevertheless creates an overall false consumer perception about the goods or services being advertised.

Civil fines are capped at $3,000, but the law does not specify if this is per ad impression, per day, or otherwise. Injunctions under the statute seeking an order stopping an ad may be a greater risk for businesses. Early enforcement actions may provide guidance about what triggers the disclosure obligation and how penalties are determined. Until uncertainties are resolved, a conservative approach would be to disclose the use of AI-generated content in ads that may be seen in Pennsylvania.

Eric Gordon and Carole Klinger

DATA PRIVACY

Risky business: ongoing risk assessment requirements for personal information processing in California

Amended California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA) regulations require documented risk assessments before initiating personal information processing actions that pose a “significant risk” to California consumers’ privacy. This includes “selling” or “sharing” personal information (including for targeted advertising), processing sensitive personal information, and using automated decision-making technology (ADMT) for significant decisions.

Assessments must weigh privacy risks against benefits, with the goal of restricting or prohibiting processing when risks outweigh benefits. They must be updated at least every three years (or within 45 days of a material change) and kept so long as such processing continues or five years after the assessment is completed, whichever is later.

Ongoing processing started before 2026 must be assessed by December 31, 2027. Summaries of assessments for processing conducted during 2026-2027, signed by a company executive under penalty of perjury, must be filed with the California Privacy Protection Agency (CPPA) by April 1, 2028. For assessments conducted after 2027, summaries must be filed no later than April 1 of the following year.

If they haven’t done so already, businesses should ensure that they are conducting and recording any required risk assessments, preparing to submit timely summaries to the CPPA, and continually monitoring new processing activities that may trigger additional assessment obligations.

Eric Gordon and Carole Klinger

INTERNATIONAL

EU – Intersection of copyright and trademarks: General Court rejects claim of earlier copyright ownership due to insufficient evidence

Salumanus, a Polish telecommunications company, filed a declaration of invalidity against Heyoptics’ trademark registration forImage not found(“LIGHTOPTICS & Design”) in Classes 9 and 35 for fiber optics goods and services.

Salumanus relied upon its claimed earlier copyright in a highly similar logo, Image not found, and Heyoptics’ bad faith. The declaration was dismissed, and Salumanus appealed to the EUIPO Board, which also dismissed it.

On appeal to the EU General Court, the claims were again rejected, on the basis that Salumanus did not provide sufficient evidence that (i) it had prior ownership of the logo to constitute an earlier copyright, or (ii) that Heyoptics acted in bad faith.

Salumanus submitted emails, product photographs, invoices, website materials, and an agreement with a graphic designer. However, the court found these materials did not establish Salumanus’ authorship, creation, or ownership of the logo before Heyoptics filed its trademark application for LIGHTOPTICS & Design. The court also rejected documents that Salumanus attempted to introduce later because they had not been submitted during the earlier proceedings. It concluded that despite similarities between the logos, the evidence was insufficient to demonstrate bad faith, as it did not establish that Heyoptics knew or should have known of Salumanus’ prior logo or intended to take advantage of it.

Businesses should maintain clear, dated records documenting creation, ownership, and use of copyright, trademarks, and other brand assets, and ensure that all relevant evidence is submitted early in a proceeding.

Darra Frino

Suriname – Trademark protection covering services is now available in Suriname

In a major step to modernize its intellectual property system, Suriname recently introduced protection for service marks, adopting the Nice Classification system.

During a formal transition between now and July 9, 2027, owners of trademark applications and registrations existing as of October 9, 2026 can request that such marks be extended to cover service classes. The original filing or registration priority date will be preserved when service classes are added during the transitional period.

Requests to add service classes to existing registrations or applications must include:

  • Identification of the relevant service classes (according to the Nice Classification)
  • Evidence of actual use of the mark in Suriname in connection with requested services (such as invoices, order confirmations, booking records, and ads)
  • Payment of the relevant fees

Given the new opportunity to secure service mark protection, trademark owners operating in Suriname should evaluate their portfolios and consider making additional filings during the transition period to secure protection and/or consider filing new service mark applications where existing rights cannot be extended.  

Maritza Schaeffer

Kiribati – Kiribati introducing new national trademark registration system  

Kiribati has introduced a new trademark registration system that will come into force on January 11, 2027. Under the existing system, trademark protection can be obtained only by extending an existing UK registration, with renewal and validity directly linked to the underlying UK right. Once the new law comes into effect, however, trademark owners can file directly in Kiribati. Registrations that were secured through the current UK-based system will remain valid, and their renewal will follow the rules of the new national act.

Brand owners with an interest in Kiribati should review their trademark portfolios and consider whether it is desirable to take advantage of the new system and file direct applications.

Maritza Schaeffer

Primary Sidebar

Search Again

  • Sitemap
© 2026 Fross Zelnick Lehrman & Zissu, P.C.®
  • Fross Zelnick and FZ are registered trademarks of Fross Zelnick Lehrman & Zissu, P.C.
  • Attorney Advertising
  • Legal & Privacy
  • Connect with us on LinkedIn
  • Contact

Stay Connected

  • People
  • Focus
    • Artificial Intelligence
    • Celebrities, Bands & Athletes
    • Consumer Products
    • Entertainment Properties
    • Fashion
    • Food & Beverage
    • Hospitality & Hotels
    • Jewelry & Watches
    • Personal Care & Cosmetics
    • Pharmaceuticals
    • Professional Services
    • Publishing
    • Sports
    • Startup & Emerging Growth
    • Toys
  • Services
    • Trademark
    • Copyright
    • Design
    • Data Privacy
    • Publicity & Privacy Rights
    • Litigation
    • International
    • Transactions
    • Social Media & Domain Names
  • Decisions
  • Newsroom
  • Our Firm
    • About Our Firm
    • Diversity & Inclusion
    • Recognition
    • Careers
    • Pro Bono
    • Contact